Discover Real Life Church

Why God Says No to a Good Prayer

God always answers prayer. He simply does not always answer with yes. Scripture shows four responses He gives when we bring Him our requests: no, slow, grow, and go. Learning how God answers prayer changes the way you pray and the way you wait. Most of us have prayed something sincere and then heard nothing back. The job did not come. The healing did not happen. The door stayed shut. In that silence it is easy to assume either that God is not listening or that you prayed it wrong. Neither is usually true. Before we get to the four answers, there are two things worth settling first: why we pray at all, and what actually spoils a prayer. Prayer Starts With the Example of Jesus When we pray, we are following the example of Jesus. Luke 5:16 records that "Jesus Himself would often slip away to the wilderness and pray." He spent an entire night in prayer before choosing His disciples. He prayed often, and He prayed in the hardest moments of His life. Matthew 26:39 places us in the Garden of Gethsemane, with the crucifixion on the horizon. "And He went a little beyond them, and fell on His face and prayed, saying, 'My Father, if it is possible, let this cup pass from Me; yet not as I will, but as You will.'" Facing the worst night of His life, Jesus went to His Father. He also prayed for the people He loved. In Luke 22:32, just before Peter would deny Him, Jesus says, "But I have prayed for you, that your faith may not fail; and you, when you have turned back, strengthen your brothers." Imagine someone walking into the room and telling you they have been praying for you. That sentence likely stayed with Peter the rest of his life. In the Gospel of John, we see Jesus spending time praying for His disciples near the end of His earthly life, before He went to the cross. There is variety in how Jesus prayed, but the pattern is unmistakable. He practiced both kinds of prayer: the ongoing, running conversation and the set-apart times of prayer. He even said He did nothing unless the Father showed Him to do it, which is another way of saying that nothing happened until it was revealed to Him in prayer. Can You Pray the Wrong Way? Yes, though probably not in the way you fear. In Matthew 6:5-8, Jesus confronts two groups over how they pray, and neither problem has anything to do with vocabulary. First, the performers. "And when you pray, you are not to be like the hypocrites, for they love to stand and pray in the synagogues and on the street corners so that they will be seen by people. Truly I say to you, they have their reward in full. But as for you, when you pray, go into your inner room, close your door, and pray to your Father who is in secret; and your Father who sees what is done in secret will reward you." This is prayer as a spiritual badge of honor, a gold star handed out in public for how often and how impressively someone prays. Second, the manipulators. "And when you are praying, do not use thoughtless repetition as the Gentiles do, for they think that they will be heard because of their many words. So do not be like them; for your Father knows what you need before you ask Him." The Gentiles prayed to a pantheon of gods, and their chants functioned more like incantations than prayers. The belief underneath was that enough repetition would force the gods to act. That heart is manipulation, the same impulse behind any spell or act of witchcraft, where the goal is to gain control or power over someone else. So what spoils prayer is the heart behind it. What does not spoil prayer is how eloquent you sound. Some people I grew up with were intimidated into silence because our church had people who prayed beautifully, quoting Scripture from memory and moving from one passage to the next without pausing. A newer believer would listen to that and think, I do not even know those verses. I cannot pray like that. Memorizing Scripture and praying it back to God is a wonderful practice. But if you are starting out, pray in short, simple, clear sentences. That is all you need. God does not need an essay from you. When we gather for nights of prayer and worship and get into circles to pray together, I encourage people to pray in sentences, not paragraphs, because the Father already knows what you need. What About Praying for the Same Thing Over and Over? There is a practice called intercession, and I believe God calls every one of us to it at some point. Intercession is standing in the presence of God, usually for a longer stretch of time, going before Him again and again about the same thing. That is not the manipulation Jesus warned against, because we are not doing it to increase our odds. We do it because God burdens us to do it and calls us to it. It is an act of faith to ask for the same thing for a long time with your hands still open, leaving Him free to answer however He wants. I can remember sitting in a hospital with a friend who had been in a horrific car accident with her daughters and had suffered severe brain trauma. My wife and I took turns with some other friends, and I would sit there and read Scripture over her. I prayed every verse in the Bible about healing over her, and when I finished, I started over. That was a good thing to do. It was a God honoring thing to do. That is intercession. How Does God Answer Prayer? He answers. We see it all through Scripture. Reading the Old Testament account of Solomon dedicating the temple, you watch as Solomon prays over that building, and then God meets with him and tells him plainly that He has heard the prayer and will answer it. That is one example among many. The real question is not whether God answers. It is what His answers look like. There are four of them. When God Says No Sometimes the request itself is off. What you are asking for can simply be wrong. I am not someone with a long list of enemies, but when I have perceived someone as one, I have been tempted to pray some of the things David prayed in the Psalms. Those prayers are descriptive, not prescriptive. When David prays against his enemies, Scripture is showing us what he did, not instructing us to copy it. So there were times I prayed, Lord, smite them, and the answer was no. Here is the part that should settle any doubt about whether a no means God is distant. God the Father said no to His own Son. In Matthew 26:39, Jesus asked that the cup pass from Him, and the answer was no. That cup could not pass. Notice the heart posture underneath the request: "Yet not as I will, but as You will." Jesus asked, and He left the Father calling the shots. When God Says Slow or Grow Sometimes the request is right, but the timing is wrong, and the answer is slow. Sometimes the request and the timing are fine, but the spiritual condition of your heart is not ready, and the answer is grow. There have been times in my life, and there will be in yours, where you ask for a genuinely good thing, and the Lord says, not yet. Other times, you ask for a good thing, and the Lord raises questions about your motives and your maturity. This happened to me directly. I was praying about what God had next for me when I was offered a promotion. More money, more authority, more influence. As I looked at it, I sensed the Lord saying it was neither the right thing nor the right time. The role included no teaching, and when I was sixteen years old, I had a calling moment where the first thing the Lord told me about my calling was that I would teach and speak for Him. I have let that word direct my steps ever since. So I turned down the promotion and told them there was another role that better aligned with my gifts and skills. That is the track I stayed on for the next ten years, and it was the right one. I have also prayed for promotions I was not ready for, and God put up a brick wall. He withholds things when the timing is wrong or when something in us needs to change first. Hurdles and Brick Walls Here is a way to tell the difference. When God calls you to something and you start moving, you will face hurdles. Jumping hurdles is fine, and it actually gives Him glory, because He gets a chance to be the one who carried you over. Occasionally you hit a brick wall instead. The question to ask then is who put it there, because it might be Him. It might be the Lord saying He does not want you going any further in this direction, either for your safety, or for your good, or simply because it is not according to His will. Our church leadership team worked through this when we began praying about our next step. I felt directed by the Lord that renovating our worship center was the move that would make the biggest impact the soonest, and we had the opportunity in front of us. As we talked it through, I told the team exactly what we were watching for: hurdles and walls. If God threw up a brick wall, we would know not to go further. Until then, we would keep walking the path He gave us peace to walk. So we took one conversation and one step at a time with our hands open, telling the Lord He could shut it down whenever He wanted. If we were not ready as a church, or if He wanted to do something in us first, that would be completely fine. When God Says Go This is the favorite answer, and it means yes. At this point, God is saying that your request, your timing, and your spiritual condition are all where they need to be, so move forward. Our responsibility in that moment is to act in faith and obey. That matters just as much as the waiting did. Not My Will, but Yours No, slow, grow, and go. Once you know how God answers prayer, silence stops feeling like rejection and starts looking like one of four responses from a Father who already knows what you need before you ask Him. The posture that holds all four together is the one Jesus took in the garden: not my will, but Your will be done. Ask boldly, keep your hands open, and let Him call the shots. Start today with one short, simple sentence. That is all He is asking for.